Monticello Homes for Sale

Sort Option
  • _score
  • Price ↓
  • Newest Listings First
  • Square Footage ↓
  • Year Built ↓
Grid
List
Map

Single Family

711 Bluewater, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,200Sqft
This is a very cute 3 bedroom, one bath home that has been very well cared for. View nature at it's best from the sun room facing the water and trees across the lake. Just down from Bluewater park where there is plenty of swimming, fishing and a nice area for family time. There are 2 permanent boat lifts. All appliances to stay with property.
$139,900

Single Family

301 Cleveland Street, Monticello, Indiana 47960

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,716Sqft
Great opportunity to be your own property manager. This 2 unit home features a 3 bedroom 1.5 bath and a 1 bedroom 1 bath unit. The structure sits on a double corner lot with alley access for off street parking or plenty of space to construct an outbuilding. Some updates include new deck on 301B, newer roof, new gutters and windows as well as recent bath updates.
$139,900

Residential

6586 Northeast Shafer Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,640Sqft
Best property on Lake Shafer! Talk about detail and amenities! This has it all. 3/4' oak stained sawn oak floors throughout. Carrera heated marble floor in master bath. Blue slate floors from India., rain forest marble in lower bath. A kitchen to die for. Over $16,000 of high end appliances. Granite tops and Amish made cabinets. Open floor plan. Two fireplaces.
$620,000

Single Family

959 MITCHELL Avenue, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,664Sqft
Very nice, well kept home located in an ideal residential neighborhood and is just 2 blocks from Blue Water Beach which offers playgrounds, picnic shelters and boat ramp access to Lake Freeman! Plenty of living space can be found on the main floor with it's 2 bedrooms, kitchen, living room & updated full bath, followed by the lower level with the third bedroom, large 2nd full bath & laun
$134,900

Residential

5102 East Shady Point Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,532Sqft
Check this out today. Beautifully remodeled home. Grainte tops, built in appliances. Newer ceramic tile floors in Kitchen and baths. Maintenance free exterior. Rec room can be added bedrooms. Comfortable screened in front porch for enjoying early mornings or sunset evenings. Two large bedrooms. Master has full bath and BR #2 bath accessible.
$299,900

Single Family

4292 E Penrod Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,104Sqft
Very nice home, on a corner lot with fantastic view of Lake Shafer. It has an easement that is approximately 70+ft at the water & road and 235 feet to the water. There are signs stating the private easement. Sellers portable lift and pier are included in sale. There is also a garage deep enough do store your boat with trailer.
$179,900

Single Family

5182 S Gingrich Court, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
427Sqft
2 Bedroom Lake Level Freeman Cottage on a peninsula with multiple views front and back of water. Nice low traffic neighborhood. Close commute to West Lafayette Area. Home has original hardwood flooring, knotty pine interior, carport for additional storage and possible patio usage.
$144,900

Single Family

713 Bluewater Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,225Sqft
PRICE REDUCED!!!! Remodeled Lake Level Lake Freeman Home with multiple decks, permanent lift w/ roof top deck, steel driven seawall. Oak Kitchen, Cedar Trim in home, Knotty Pine ceilings. Wrap Around deck with Lake views from many different angle s. 9ft. Crawl Space with overhead door for additional storage of water toys.
$214,900

Single Family

4867 NW Shafer Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,462Sqft
Ever dream of living in the proverbial house at the top of the lane - you know, the one with the bird's eye view of the rest of the neighborhood? Well, this IS that house . . .
$249,900

Single Family

314 N Railroad Street, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,405Sqft
Located in a convenient in town location, this 2/3 bedroom, 1 bath home sets on a large lot that includes a 1.5 car garage (16x22). Overall a low maintenance exterior that includes vinyl siding, dimensional shingles, and vinyl replacement windows. Interior offers a huge living room, updated kitchen, & spacious laundry room.
$79,900

Single Family

816 W Washington Street, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,488Sqft
This is a rare find, this custom built, one owner home has original hardwood floors that look amazing. The 3 bedrooms all are large and have nice size closets. The main bath has a larger than normal size door that would easily accommodate those with wheel chairs or walkers. The hallway is also wider than normal ranch homes.
$170,000

Single Family

12330 W Crest Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,167Sqft
LAKE FREEMAN RETREAT! Treat yourself, friends & family to good times and lake fun with this multi-faceted 5 bedroom lake home ideal for extra guests. Main level offers an open living area for entertaining as well as an XL water-view deck, plus 3 bedrooms. Lower level has an additional guest bedroom, family room & sun porch as well as an additional deck overlooking the lake.
$299,900

Single Family

11778 N Vista Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,848Sqft
Updated cottage setting on 70 ft of prime Lake Freeman frontage with spectacular views and incredible lake front improvements! The lakeside setting takes full advantage of the views from the double permanent electric boat lift with a huge party deck above, fire pit, covered deck, and a screened in porch.
$269,900

Single Family

506 E OHIO, Monticello, Indiana 47960

6Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
4,492Sqft
Live on Lake Freeman in style with this spacious 6 bedroom 3 bathroom contemporary ranch. You will enjoy the expansive views of the lake from multiple decks and patios perfect for entertaining all your family and friends. Featuring 90 feet of prime lake frontage with new steel sea wall and your own private board walk on the lake, a covered electric boat lift and two waver runner docks.
$399,900

Single Family

11392 N 1175 W, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,479Sqft
HAS YOUR LAKE HOME SEARCH BEEN PUZZLING?? ALL THE PIECES ARE HERE! Plenty of 'positives' and potential can be found with this 3 Bed/2 Bath Lake Freeman home; Open living space w/ fireplace, XL dining or family area surrounded by windows and water-views, 2 bedrooms & full bath on the main level; Finished walk-out basement features another bedroom and full bathroom, XL living area w/fireplace
$239,900

Single Family

516 S Bluff Street, Monticello, Indiana 47960

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,529Sqft
This home has character galore from the plentiful windows for natural lighting to the mostly hardwood floors and natural woodwork. This home has a great covered front porch, 1 car detached garage and fenced back yard! All rooms are spacious in size. Formal dining room. Wash & dryer hook-up in kitchen area. Pantry off of kitchen offers plenty of extra storage.
$72,500

Single Family

2754 N BAERS Court, Monticello, Indiana 47960

5Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,961Sqft
LAKEFRONT, LAND AND LODGING GALORE!! Rare find on Lake Shafer with nearly an acre of land and over 200 ft. of waterfront. The location just inside a small bay with main lake views and access at your doorstep but calm waters for swimming and relaxing is an added bonus.
$310,000

Single Family

8519 N KIGER Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,938Sqft
IT'S A LITTLE BIT COUNTRY & A LITTLE BIT LAKE LIFE TOO! Whether you are looking for your rest and relaxation in a rural, spacious outdoor setting, or sun and fun on Lake Shafer, this rustic yet contemporary 3000+ sq. ft. home with ceramic tile and hardwood flooring throughout, has what you need.
$299,900

Single Family

317 N Dewey Street, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,696Sqft
Very well maintained 3 bedroom and 2 1/2 bath home with open concept kitchen and living room. The kitchen has some stainless steel appliances and a kitchen island for all your baking and cooking needs! Very nice hardwood floors through out. There is a Master bedroom and full bath on the main level as well as a half of bath in the laundry area.
$129,900

Single Family

310 S RAILROAD Street, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
752Sqft
Good Things Come in Small Packages! This is One Of Them! This snug little 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom charmer features brand new flooring throughout, stainless appliances, freshly painted walls and cabinets, recessed lighting, a huge back yard, side deck, a covered front porch with stone front and so much more.
$99,900

Single Family

4513 E OAKCREST Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,816Sqft
This home is a MUST SEE. Lovely renovations. 3 bedroom, 2 bath, attached garage, and community easement to Lake Shafer. SPACIOUS 2 story home with 3BR /2.5 BA It has a large Family room PLUS BONUS Mancave room. OVERSIZED 2 CAR GARAGE IS AN ADDED BONUS! All appliances are included. There will be new garage doors installed within the next 2 weeks.
$250,000

Single Family

9692 N Downey Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,694Sqft
GREAT VIEWS out every window! Property has upper lot with electricity and room for boats & RV's. Fishermen and water fans will love the 79' of quiet riverfront, private on the property boat ramp and fish house or garden shed with sink on the lower lot. Enjoy a bug free summer in the gazebo or screened porch.
$160,000

Single Family

5091 E Shady Point, Monticello, Indiana 47960-7252

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,144Sqft
Quite cottage on main Lake Shafer with a amazing view! There is a concrete seawall with a deck overlooking the waterfront. This cottage has lots of potential to make this your very own.
$139,900

Single Family

6783 N Skaggs Court, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
1Parking(s)
10Picture(s)
1,352Sqft
Enjoy the peace and serenity on a quiet part of Lake Shafer. The home has a beautiful panoramic view of the lake and surrounding area, and great neighbors. This gorgeous 3 bedroom 2 bath home is just waiting for you! Has a newer garage with electric. Boat lift is electric and can service a boat of 18-20 ft. Enjoy the view with your family from the waterfront deck.
$190,000

Single Family

321 S Bluff Street, Monticello, Indiana 47960

5Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
3,584Sqft
PRICE REDUCED !!! Preserved Civil War Era Brick 5 bed/2.5 bath on 3 city lots with Modern Updates. 10 ft. ceilings, 7" base trim/crown molding, original hardwood flooring, brick/tile flooring, 2 main level fireplaces.
$246,900

Single Family

3743 N WEST SHAFER Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,860Sqft
NOTHING TO DO BUT ENJOY THE VIEW! Plenty of amenities, minimal maintenance to be had with this newer construction home on Lake Shafer. Main floor offers an open concept with cathedral ceiling, floor-to-ceiling windows, high-end remodeled kitchen w/quartz counter-tops, and spacious living room with an in-wall gas fireplace, plus the Master bed/bath; Add to this the 25' deck overlooking the lake.
$429,900

Single Family

W 1100 N St, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
4Picture(s)
1,500Sqft
Brand new beautiful 3 bedroom 2 bath home being built! Does this look like your dream home? Check out the floor plan and watch as the home is being constructed. Perfect area, not to far from town with the added bonus of the peace of country living.
$189,900

Single Family

3139 N LAKESHORE Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

5Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,120Sqft
FANTASTIC 2120 SQ FT LAKE SHAFER MAIN LAKE HOME WITH 50' WATERFRONT BUILT IN 2007, FEATURING 3 BEDROOMS, EACH WITH ITS OWN FULL BATHS. BEAUTIFUL KITCHEN WITH GRANITE COUNTER TOPS, STAINLESS STEEL APPLIANCES, LARGE SCREENED PORCH OVERLOOKING THE WATER WITH ATTACHED DECK. NEWER GARAGE WITH TWO VERY NICE BEDROOMS ABOVE HEATED AND AIR CONDITIONED.
$399,990

Single Family

814 E Terrace Bay Court, Monticello, Indiana 47960

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,113Sqft
The perfect lake house getaway! BRING YOUR WATER TOYS because this home has the room! Prime lake level lot on Lake Freeman with a steel seawall. There are 2 electric boat lifts, 2 manual boat lifts and a jet ski lift. This 4 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom home is ready for fun and relaxation! 4th bedroom is above the sunroom, perfect for guests.
$315,000

Single Family

8020 N West Shafer Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
8Picture(s)
792Sqft
What a Buy!! This 2 bed 1 bath cottage has been remodeled and has great view of the water! Enjoy this year round or just a weekend getaway on lake Shafer! It has 20 ft of water frontage to enjoy the water.
$99,900

Single Family

10520 N Corley Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960-8129

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,152Sqft
Move in ready! This could be your summer lake home or year round home. Enjoy your summers on beautiful Lake Freeman with your family! This home offers 3 bedrooms and one full bathroom and one half of bath, sunroom, vaulted ceilings, open floor plan, spacious kitchen and many updates! This is a lake level lot and has 900 sq ft of deck space for entertaining.
$169,900

Single Family

3568 E Bailey Road, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,482Sqft
You will have plenty of time for relaxing by the water from this LOW MAINTENANCE, updated lake home. A 1 story home that sets on a peaceful bay with beautiful views and a short boat ride out to the main lake activity. Lakeside offers all composite decking, covered bar, party deck above the permanent boat lift and a steel sea wall.
$304,900

Single Family

11821 PIRATES ROOST RD, Monticello, Indiana 47960

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,368Sqft
SET YOUR SIGHTS AND SAILS FOR THIS FANTASTIC LAKE FREEMAN HOME ON PIRATES ROOST ROAD! You'll find all of your lake living needs in this beautiful property featuring: 1) the contemporary 4 Bed/2.5 Bath home with it's open concept main floor living area/custom kitchen, additional family room/den, and walk-out/water-view patio access basement.
$475,000

Single Family

3411 E Stahl Road, Monticello, Indiana 47960

5Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,184Sqft
Experience lake living from one of the best locations on Lake Shafer/Big Monon Bay. Enjoy the benefits of life on a bay. Bay living offers beautiful views, a quiet setting and safe swimming. Situated on a lake level lot, this home offers 5/6 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 2184 sqft, an attached 2 car garage, detached 1.5 car garage, & low maintenance composite decks.
$274,900

Single Family

11228 N Lower Lakeshore Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,036Sqft
Lake Level 3 bedroom 2 bath Brick Main Lake Freeman Home. Tile and Hardwood flooring, oak kitchen, pier/deck & hot tub at waterfront. Oversized det. garage with hook-up for RV Parking. Carport of additional parking. Updated furnace/central a/c and electrical. Crown Molding and finished ceilings. Maintenance Free exterior home. Fenced Side Yard.
$334,900

Single Family

11922 W Pirates Roost Road, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
2Picture(s)
748Sqft
Cute small cottage steps away from the Lake Freeman. Sold as is.
$105,000

Single Family

428 Turpie St Street, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
7Picture(s)
868Sqft
Move-in condition and convenient location! This 2 bedroom home had updated windows, furnace, and carpet. Some hardwood floors under carpet. Gas or Elec. hook-up for stove and dryer. Attached oversized one car garage with access from the back side alley.
$72,500

Single Family

3153 N Lakeshore Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960

1Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
1,240Sqft
With attention to detail, This 1 bedroom home has all of the amenities you could ask for. From a tiled garage floor to hardwood floors on the upper level. There is a screened in porch and maintenance free decking. The home is being sold with most of the furnishings in it so all you have to do is show up and start enjoying. There is even a steel sea wall at the water front.
$277,900

Single Family

4682 North Reuben Court, Monticello, Indiana 47960

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
1,612Sqft
This Lake Shafer home offers many recent updates as well as great views of the main lake. Outside offers an enormous paver patio(new in 2017) that includes a natural gas firepit, commercial grade lighting and a gas line for your grill. Large 24 x 24 deck with a waterslide over the water which covers the two permanent lifts.
$369,900

Single Family

606 N Monticello Street, Winamac, Indiana 46996-1141

3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
2Parking(s)
10Picture(s)
1,525Sqft
High ceilings, ornate woodwork, a brick fireplace, and hardwood floors under the carpet are just a few of the unique amenities of this home. The covered front porch gives the home a nice curb appeal as well as a great place to relax and enjoy friends and family on your porch swing. This 3 bedroom home has a large dining room, living room, and bedrooms .
$99,900

Single Family

5531 E Sheridan Road, Monticello, Indiana 47960

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,746Sqft
4 bedroom 2.5 bath Ranch in Freeman View Subdivision South of Monticello with nice lake easement/beach area/boat launch & pier access. 3 spacious lots with corner location, Good access to Lafayette/West Lafayette area. Spacious floor plan with split bedroom layout, nice master suite, vaulted & tray ceilings, recessed lighting, open kitchen/dining/living area.
$284,900

Single Family

11683 N BRIARWOOD DR, Monticello, Indiana 47960

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
3,600Sqft
This home located in one of Monticello's elite subdivisions of high end homes has a park like setting with country front porch and open rear deck with trex flooring.Inside is all open concept with cathedral ceilings and open stairway.Kitchen has solid surface counter tops with updated appliances through out.Master suite has separate Jacuzzi and custom walk in tile shower.
$359,900

Single Family

1214 East 49TH Street, Indianapolis, Indiana 46205

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
8Picture(s)
1,107Sqft
Wonderful 2-bedroom SoBro home with lots of updates including kitchen, bathroom, carpet, roof, furnace, plumbing, electrical & A/C. Lots of natural light throughout plus a basement. Enjoy the front porch or relax on the rear wooden deck. Just blocks from the Monon Trail & walking distance to SoBro restaurants, cafes and the Redline.
$129,000

Single Family

11650 W Briarwood Dr. Courts, Monticello, Indiana 47960

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
3,170Sqft
Custom home in prime location! 4-5 Bedroom home with all the amenities you've been wanting. Hickory kitchen cabinets with corian counter tops, large island, and black stainless appliances. 2-Zone heating and a/c systems and built in bose sound system. Pillars in great room with hardwood floors and open to the dining and kitchen area.
$369,900

Single Family

11688 W Briarwood Drive, Monticello, Indiana 47960-4746

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
2,586Sqft
Yes you CAN own a home in the highly sought-after, upscale, private neighborhood of Stoney Creek, and you can do it for under 275K! The Stoney Creek subdivision, established in 1997, is a private neighborhood replete with beautiful executive homes carefully constructed around the natural landscape.
$259,900

Single Family

5266 E LAKE RD 65 W- Monticello- Indiana 47960

1Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
6Picture(s)
612Sqft
Nice cottage with view of Lake Schafer. Convenient to restaurant. Large living room. Storage shed and privacy fenced patio. Access to playground, volleyball courts, horseshoes and lakeside beach.
$35,900

Single Family

3830 N Camp Munsee Court, Monticello, Indiana 47960

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
3,000Sqft
This is a must see to appreciate home on a lake level lot across from the Tippecanoe Country Club. It boasts a master bedroom on the main floor with a full bath. The den off the garage could easily be converted into 2 nice size bedrooms, each with a large closet. A beautifully landscaped yard with a panoramic view of Lake Shafer.
$415,500

Single Family

2371 N Untalulti Street, Monticello, Indiana 47960

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
10Picture(s)
600Sqft
This cute cottage is in a PUD and considered a condo. It offers 2 bedrooms and 1 bath and views of Lake Shafer and Indiana Beach. It is within walking distance of the South Entrance to the IB and has a dedicated spot on the water for a pier/boat lift.
$57,000
65 Results returned.Per Page
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!